Dear KC:
Looking forward to hearing more of Sharon Jones and The Dap Kings. I also hear a good instrument in your other offering, 'Miss Li'. Her handlers tho' are attempting a landing on Bjork's approach- in similar terrain, and I got no patience with bandwagons. Fact is I got to settle an issue with the king of all soul-lite- Mr. Tom Waits.
Mr. Waits' maintaining a false and forced growling thru his tenor says one thing to me: "Poseable". in some artists restricted sounds represent creative alternatives, doing well with what one's got, or even metaphors for the dumbing-down of culture and values. But this sound suggests at once portable appropriation of achievement in an underclass- and and under-valuing of the self, as an unworthy native next-to-nothing. Taking it off the black man, and discounting white privilege. Two tired tickets. Too bad- b/c Waits' writing is lately becoming free.
Mr. Waits' maintaining a false and forced growling thru his tenor says one thing to me: "Poseable". in some artists restricted sounds represent creative alternatives, doing well with what one's got, or even metaphors for the dumbing-down of culture and values. But this sound suggests at once portable appropriation of achievement in an underclass- and and under-valuing of the self, as an unworthy native next-to-nothing. Taking it off the black man, and discounting white privilege. Two tired tickets. Too bad- b/c Waits' writing is lately becoming free.
Now usually the evidence of a "good song" gets revealed in further interpretation- by others. So- Where are Waits' interpreters? Maybe he's scared them off. Instead we get imitators of Waits' all-over imitation. Waits' own approach has always been an re-hash of "classic" Hollywood memes and stray retro morsels of "style" into nostalgic audio travelogues- or visits with eccentric beat scene-sters. Trading in appropriation, distortions of proportion immediately tends to develop.
Next Miss Li's conducter drive her to board the meme-train bandwagon. Her ticket is stamped in a cool carny font: "New Orleans Funeral". We hear a fun brass band- then stops at a "Gator Town" full of sliding gut-bucket strings. But Miss Li's also chugging a circus-train of fellow-travelers: toy piano, glockenspiel, saw, theramin, nose-flutes... There'll be hidden charges from post-production room-effects; and in such rooms anyone can pick up "Foley" unawares.
It can be hard to even hear as "songs" what the Waits' of the world are doing- until they appear onstage. Because "the live show" is so different from the "recorded product". We get to see who's doing what- singer, writer, engineer, personality-- and the big kicker of the 20th century, still with us: the creative ensemble. To me there's a single criteria to having fun- Is it a creative situation? Are we about making connections? Am I touching the real, the me? You dont need Milli-Vanilli melt-downs to feel left off in lonely town.
For me this nostalgic musical trend is missing one key which uplifted the similar but fully autocratic sonic experiments of Brian Wilson: actual invention. Waits may be a clever conjurer of the fraying edges of our always familiar past, but how often has he created a true revelation, a unique or unknown sound or vision?
This style of music- whether it venerates burlesque, klezmer, regional radio, or every last Euro/mediterranean subculture not yet strip-mined for memes- it's technically sophisticated, and it offers us something we are told our primal spiritual selves still require: Ritual- as the re-enactment of music and musicians.
But will it live itself? By Waits' own croaking evidence his spirit and sound still wont sit comfortably in own stomped-in, wanna-be crushed-down male-&-more-privilege throat.
At least Miss Li doesnt have any such problems!
No comments:
Post a Comment
Oh yeah? Write: